Call Now

Call Now

Call Now

Blog

How To Address An Unfavorable Custody Evaluation

How To Address An Unfavorable Custody Evaluation

Courts routinely order custody evaluations in cases so a person trained with what is key in a child’s psycho-social development can investigate the case and speak with the children and make a custody recommendation to the court of what is in the child’s best interest. Some judges place great value on a custody evaluation and others do not. Nevertheless, if you receive an unfavorable custody evaluation, it is not necessarily the end of your case. These three sound approaches to address an unfavorable custody evaluation depending on your case.

When it is apparent the evaluator did not consider (or have available to them) certain significant information, it is often necessary to conduct discovery1 on the custody evaluator to find out what documents and other materials they obtained and relied upon to prepare to make recommendations to the court in his/her report. If key materials are omitted, then this can be used by your counsel on cross-exam of the evaluator to establish the missing material and corresponding flaws in the evaluator’s work. Then, coupled with your own testimony or exhibits, you can present an accurate picture to the court of the real controlling custody dynamics and why the report’s conclusions as to legal or physical custody and parenting time are inaccurate—and what they should be based on the evidence presented.

Another very effective way to address an inaccurate custody evaluation is to retain your own expert to analyze the custody evaluation. In this case, normally you obtain the errant experts underlying file and report and have your expert work through it and testify to its shortfalls and what the evidence really supports, if anything, as it relates to custody and parenting time. Alternatively, this expert may direct that without certain information, there is no viable way to support the expert’s conclusions and the report should be considered of little weight. For this to be most effective, your expert should have more education, training, and experience than the original evaluator in order to be perceived as credible by the trial court.

Finally, and perhaps the best way to take on an adverse custody evaluation is to have a forensic child psychologist perform another custody evaluation and cover the missing materials, testing or considerations and issue a dueling report. Not all courts will entertain a second evaluation because it puts the children back through the evaluation process, but on the other hand, this is not all that uncommon either. The key is to make a compelling motion to the court as to why a second evaluation is necessary for the children’s best interests.

While a negative custody evaluation is not the best situation to be in, it certainly is not the end of your case if you carefully consider how to address it. This is the work of a skilled family law advocate. This blog is written by attorneys at Ciyou & Dixon, P.C. who handle domestic cases of all types, as well as appeals, throughout the state. This material is written for general educational purposes and is not intended as legal advice or material that should be relied upon in any given case. This blog is not a solicitation for services. It is an advertisement.


  1. The investigator must provide his or her file of underlying data and reports, complete texts of diagnostic reports made the investigator and the names and addresses of all persons whom the investigator consulted. Ind. Code 31-17-2-12(c).
Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on pinterest
Pinterest
Share on email
Email

We Listen & Care

Proven & experienced attorneys successfully advocating & resolving complex cases for over 25 years

Quick Contact

Need to talk now? Fill out the quick form below and we will contact you directly.
Blog Categories

Get In Touch

We're available to answer your questions 24/7.

Contact Us

Please fill out the form below and we will be in touch with you shortly.

Ciyou & Dixon, P.C., is a law firm located in Indianapolis, Indiana. We serve clients in six core practice areas: family lawappellate practicefirearms lawgeneral practicepersonal injury and criminal law.

Call Now

Copyright © 2021 Ciyou & Dixon, P.C., Attorneys at Law. All rights reserved. This Site does not provide legal advice; please review the disclaimer for other limitations. Privacy Policy

Based in Indianapolis and founded in 1995, Ciyou & Dixon, P.C. is a niche law firm focused on successfully dealing with the complexities of divorce, high-conflict child custody and family law. Known for their ability to solve extremely complex situations with high quality work and responsiveness, Ciyou & Dixon will guide you every step of the way. The family law attorneys at Ciyou & Dixon, P.C. will help you precisely identify your objectives and the means to reach your desired result. In addition, this practice focus is augmented by the firm's other three core areas, namely appellate advocacy, civil practice, and firearms law. Life is uncertain. Be certain of your counselSM.

Indianapolis Divorce Attorneys, Ciyou & Dixon, P.C. of Indianapolis, Indiana, offers legal services for Indianapolis, Zionsville, Noblesville, Carmel, Avon, Anderson, Danville, Greenwood, Brownsburg, Geist, Fortville, McCordsville, Muncie, Greenfield, Westfield, Fort Wayne, Fishers, Bloomington, Lafayette, Marion County, Hamilton County, Hendricks County, Allen County, Delaware County, Morgan County, Hendricks County, Boone County, Vigo County, Johnson County, Hancock County, and Tippecanoe County, Indiana.